Once, as a senior high school basketball player, a teammate and I decided one evening to drive a few miles north up Highway 61 to the Trophy Inn, a Kimmswick, MO bar, and have a couple of after practice cold beers. It was the kind of roadhouse you would expect to find a sign hanging over the urinal that said, "Don't eat the big white mint." Their lax age carding policies were well known to us.
Sitting at the bar that night were two high school basketball coaches I immediately recognized: Coach Denver Miller of Kirkwood High School and our own Coach Arvel Popp. Like a cat out of a tree, we reversed field, hastily slipping out the same back door we had just entered. Hopefully, unnoticed. The next day, before practice, Coach Popp called my accomplice and myself into his office. “Boys,” he said, “I been drinking at the Trophy Inn for 20 years. Find a new spot.”
For my junior and senior years Coach Popp was my high school varsity basketball coach at Crystal City, MO High School. I graduated in 1975. I never had a buddy-buddy relationship with Coach Popp. Our interactions were from my side, polite and respectful, but I never thought of him as a friend or even a mentor. He was my coach.
We had a pretty good team. Back then each quarter was started with a center court jump ball. One night, we were 10 points behind at halftime to an inferior opponent when Coach Popp inspired us with a locker room two-pronged strategic adjustment: “Let’s get the tip and remember boys we shoot at the other basket this half.” He then went to his office to smoke a cigarette. Several of my teammates moved to the shower room to do the same. Inspired, kind of, we stormed from the locker room and won easily. I never felt that Coach Popp burdened us with over coaching. I decided to become a high school basketball coach. How hard could this gig be? In his career Coach Popp won over 700 games.
In 1948 and already an established success, Coach Popp was lured away from Dexter, MO High School to take the reins of the Hornets. He stayed for 27 years, building a Hall of Fame career. A Southeast Missouri native of the town of Perryville and a World War II vet, Coach Popp was an enigmatic leader, aloof and disengaged from the community. He ran his teams as an unbending disciplinarian, totally above the grasp and influence of any of the town’s power brokers. Renowned in his younger days as a barroom brawler who seldom came up short with his fists, Coach Popp made and lived by his own rules.
Coach Popp had a scowl that could freeze a basketball player in midair. He was Hornet athletics, serving in the dual roles of Head Varsity Football Coach and Head Varsity Boys’ Basketball Coach. As an afterthought, he was also Athletic Director.
Coach Popp maintained an omnipotent stance during his reign. The South Pacific combat war veteran was the Lord of the Manor, his players the Serfs. When I made mistakes, Coach Popp used his vitriolic tongue to correct me in front of my teammates. It was his way of toughening me up. I knew that he wanted me to play a little harder and I went out and played a little harder—sometimes.
Today, Coach Popp is remembered in Crystal City with reverence accorded to a patron saint. The high school gym, whose construction he oversaw in the mid 1950’s, is now named The Arval B. Popp Gymnasium.
On the heels of the landmark 1954 Supreme Court Brown v Topeka Board of Education decision outlawing school racial segregation, in the fall of 1955 Coach Popp’s football team suited up four black players, the first team in the area to do so. He was given his due for a move many credit for a relatively smooth local school desegregation process. In most small rural Missouri communities in the 1950’s and 60’s, the resentment from the school segregationists spilled into the streets. Not in my hometown.
The Hornet football juggernaut of the day out-trumped even racial prejudice. The town in the vernacular of the day seemed to say, “if those colored boys can help the team put the pigskin in the end zone, then give ‘em a uniform.” Eight years before Martin Luther King’s “I Have A Dream” speech, ten years before Bloody Sunday in Selma and thirteen years before Perry Wallace would integrate Southeast Conference basketball at Vanderbilt, Coach Popp fielded an integrated football team.
How much of this principled stance should go NOT to Coach Popp but instead to a progressive school board dominated by college educated local Pittsburg Plate Glass factory administrators, is open to debate. Furthermore, the Jim Crow era Crystal City Starr black elementary school did not close its doors until 1960. Why wait an additional five years to fully integrate? Elementary students could not help the football team? This slight is still a point of consternation for older community blacks who bristle to this day at mention of the local board’s historical acclaim for racial progressiveness.
Many of my black athletic classmates never played basketball for Coach Popp. Ironically, one of our biggest rivals, the local catholic high school, St. Pius, had for over a decade been fueled by black basketball players who had attended the Crystal City public schools through 8th grade, before (perhaps for a fairer shake) moving for high school across town to the private school.
As a white 1920’s product of the state’s bootheel, an area near Mississippi, Coach Popp would have had little exposure growing up to racial tolerance. For the first half of his life, Coach Popp lived under state laws that mandated racial segregation; everything from education, to housing, to public restrooms. Interracial intimate relations were not only against the law, but in extreme cases led to lynchings, one in Missouri as late as 1933. The legacies of racial discrimination are deeply ingrained in Missouri.
Coach Popp was like all of us, a product of his times. Is it in this retrospective context how the racial culture Coach Popp built and oversaw as the leader of CCHS athletics for almost three decades be judged?
In the mid-18th century, Thomas Jefferson impregnated his 14-year-old slave. In his time, the future President and founder of the University of Virgina was viewed as a national treasure. We still to this day name monuments after him. His face adorns Mount Rushmore. Crystal City is in Jefferson County. But his type of pedophiliac Epstein-like behavior today would draw universal scorn and likely lead to Jefferson’s imprisonment.
If America can judge Jefferson’s life as a total body of work, tempered by the ethics of his time, can I do the same for Coach Popp? He was no neo-fascistic racist. But there were some post-World War II coaches, cut from the same social cloth era as Coach Popp, who bucked the racial stereotyping of the times. North Carolina’s Dean Smith was one - brave coaches who used their influential voices to make often-unpopular statements for racial social justice. However, Coach Popp was not one.
If my black classmates had been on the basketball team, I may not have played much. My black classmate the late Elroy “Jaw Man” Bequette, a local playground basketball legend, never played a minute of high school basketball for Coach Popp. Jaw Man eventually played four years of college basketball at the JUCO and NCAA Division I level. At CCHS in 1975, that is just the way it was.
Perhaps, Coach Popp hung on too long. According to players from his early Hornet years, he was a sharp-tongued disciplinarian and notorious perfectionist. But hard-nosed old school coaches like him, by 1975, were out of their element, did not relate to a youth culture weaned on the chaos of Vietnam, the Civil Right movement and Watergate. Questioning authority we viewed as our birthright.
Today, my hometown is a bedroom community of daily rush hour commuters. But Crystal City was in 1975 still a multi-generational blue-collar factory town built around a melting pot of racial diversity – and Coach Popp’s Hornets were the social glue that bound all facets cohesively together. To our parents he was the coach who had turned the boys of their class into men. And he did not suffer slackers gladly. But, by 1975 he was on his last legs. To us, Coach Popp was an alien who had descended in a pod from outer space. He laughed at the wrong places. He was irascible, cantankerous, immovable ol' Coach Popp.
We had a younger hip Assistant Coach in Mr. Rolla Herbert. With his long hair and mastery of current jargon, he became our sounding board. It was more than just an age disparity. Mr. Herbert had a background of closeness to his players I doubt he ever lost, a trait Coach Popp, at any age, I doubt ever had. Once on an away game bus ride, Coach Popp joked that with Coach Herbert around, it allowed him as head coach to be the evil coach.
After the 1976 season, Coach Popp retired. For several years after his retirement, he served CCHS in a new role as a substitute teacher. I found that to be out of character for the Coach Popp I had known. My younger brothers were in school then, and they found him engaging and lighthearted. He even let his hair grow over his ears.
Coach Popp passed away on January 25, 1996, at the age of 81.
So, who was Arvel Popp? As the years have passed, my memories of Coach Popp have become more nuanced, the discordance bouncing around in my head for the last 50 years. He was a man of his time, but it was not a good time. I do respect what he did professionally. He will always be, and justifiably so, a legend in my hometown.







